You are viewing [info]thumpaflash's journal

 
 
29 July 2010 @ 07:16 am
Has The ADA Really Helped Change Attitudes Towards Deaf Employment?  

Folks:

As I continue to meander along the employment search highway, I've noticed a disturbing trend...One that I thought had begun to turn a corner, but now am not so sure of.  I'm not unrealistic, I know what the job market is like; it is a rough and tumble world right now just waiting to chew up and spit out job-seekers of ALL types right now.

However, as a professional with 17 years of relevant experience in my chosen field, with 2 degrees and numerous accomplishments under my belt, with a fairly extensive network of colleagues and contacts, I have landed exactly TWO in-person interviews and ONE phone interview in two plus months of searching, and NONE of those resulted in a call-back or even a courtesy email in reply to my follow up emails.  For someone who has been employed continously since 1986, and have been a hiring manager myself, this was shocking.  In my years of interviewing and hiring, I NEVER failed to respond to a follow up inquiry from a job-seeker, irregardless of whether or not I intended to make an offer.  I ALWAYS attempted to interview and consider ALL candidates irregardless of race, gender, disability, etc.  I have hired women, minorities, and at least one person with a disability.  I think, if they were asked, every single one of them would say I was fair, if nothing else.  For me, the ability of the person to do the job, with or without accommodation, was and always will be, the primary consideration.  I could care less about the other stuff as long as they were the best person for the job, PERIOD.

A little background for you.  After the first month of fruitless job search, I decided to initiate a little test to identify what may be the reason for the lack of interest.  I sought out 10 job opportunities, all with the same basic qualifications/requirements, and ALL of which I met at least the minimum requirements.  For 5 of those jobs (group 1), I submitted my initial resume, which listed my VP (videophone) number, and also in my achievements/interests section, listed some of the advocacy work I have done for the deaf and hard of hearing.  For the other 5 jobs (group 2), I submitted the same resume, but without my VP number or any of my advocacy work listed.

The results?  From group 1, I received ZERO interest.  NO emails, no phone calls, NOTHING. NADA.  From group 2, I received 3 contacts.  All of them led to at least an interview, but nothing further, despite my follow up contact with the interviewers.

Now, you tell me what that sounds like?  I truly hope Obama's profession to make the federal government a role model of hiring those with disabilities takes root.  I disagree with the man's politics, but applaud him if there is REAL effort made to educate the workforce employers about the benefits of hiring those with a disability.  I DO NOT WANT THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO GROW BIGGER necessarily, BUT I would like to see attitudes changed, with employers taking applicants with a disability seriously.  Needless to say, I do NOT send out my initial resume anymore, just the revised one with my home phone number listed instead of my VP number, and no advocacy work listed either.

But for now, while the ADA may have opened doors in housing, public accommodation, and other various and sundry areas of everyday living, it appears that change in employment attitudes is still the deaf Atlantis: a mythical paradise not yet found.  That's a shame.  So much talent goes unused or unrecognized because of small-minded and ignorant people who can't see the forest for the trees. Isn't 20 years long enough for employers to have learned from the ADA by now?


 
 
( 7 comments — Leave a comment )
(Anonymous) on July 29th, 2010 02:37 pm (UTC)
What does your VP number look like? Does it look any different from hearing phone numbers? If they look different, try using a relay company that will give you a number that looks just like a hearing person's number. If it is the same, try using a different relay company. Some of them answer the phone differently.

Some people have different feelings on how to go about the job search. Some people feel that they should go ahead and put identifying information about their disability on their resume. That way, the companies that do discriminate, won't waste your time by calling you in for an interview. If you put identifying information about your disability, then those who contact you will not have a problem with you being deaf. Others feel you should not put your disability information in the resume, but let them find out at the interview. This way, you have a chance to prove your skills to them.
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on July 30th, 2010 03:29 pm (UTC)
My VP number on the resume, for ease of out of state employers, was the 1-866 number. In speaking with some people, I've become aware that they are VERY aware of what a VP number is, and actually, one employer that I had the phone interview with was okay with it, she even mentioned how her company had been hit by Nigerian scammers utilizing VP in the past. That made her learn more about it so she was comfortable, but I do know people have expressed that they won't return calls to a VP number. Thanks for the suggestions, I believe I'm just going to leave my resume as is, and go from there.
(Anonymous) on August 1st, 2010 07:12 am (UTC)
VP?
Nigerian scammers now using VPs?! I've heard they use internet relay services until the services started blocking out of country IP numbers.

So Nigerians do learn ASL?
(Anonymous) on July 29th, 2010 04:30 pm (UTC)
Job Prospects
What you shared reveals this cold hard truth. I don't think ADA will make much difference in how other employers view disabled people when it comes to hiring. One thing I have noticed, and I work in the federal sector, is that whenever there is a disability quota related to management's evaluation of their job, they tend to hire the disabled if the expectation is that they increase disabled workforce by, say 5%. If anything, the federal government is supposed to be a role model for hiring of disabled. Will that even work? What if there were automatic incentives when private sector hires the disabled? Then again, there are deaf people working at jobs they don't even know how to perform! Shocking. I recently went to a conference for employees of similar position, met several deaf people and was shocked, totally shocked to see this person not doing the job our position requires us to. This is embarrassing, and is no wonder deaf people have a hard time getting hired. The proper thing to do is to approach your boss and demand on the job training and not take advantage of the lack of knowledge so that one can read a novel at their desk. Shameful!

;)

Candy
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on July 30th, 2010 03:33 pm (UTC)
Re: Job Prospects
Candy:

Nice to see you commenting on here! Welcome. And yes, it is the cold, hard truth. Kind of stinks, but we just have to fight through it. As for those who don't even know how to do their jobs, as far as I'm concerned, they give all the deaf and hard of hearing a bad name and need to take your advice noted above and learn their jobs. As much pride as I take in doing a job and doing it well, I'm OFFENDED there are people who won't show the initiative or the ambition to do their jobs properly. Anyway, thanks for commenting!
(Anonymous) on July 29th, 2010 11:45 pm (UTC)
The law can only do so much. It still sucks, though. Keep on trucking! I wish you all the best of luck.
(Anonymous) on August 1st, 2010 07:20 am (UTC)
networking at NAD confs
That's an interesting experiment!!!

A few workshops at Philly NAD conf dealt with employment. Perhaps you can take a look at the workshop presenter bio. list (still on the NAD website?) and see what networking you can do by email.

One event was very interesting...the Corporate Best Practices - Accommodations and Accessibility Worksop. Panelists were Seth Bravin of IBM, Li Ye Chen of GE, and Sacha Klein of Booz Allen Hamilton. Seth seems to want to do this again for 2012 NAD conf (in KY...your state!) and form a professional networking group. You probably can google their names and find their email addresses to network if you wish.