You are viewing [info]thumpaflash's journal

 
 
01 January 2009 @ 02:22 pm
Deaf Apathy....  


Apathy is defined as "a lack of emotion or an indifference to things in general", and it is certainly rearing it's ugly head somewhat in the deaf community.  One thing I have noticed that is a sad commentary about the qualities that define and perpetuate the stereotypes about the deaf community, is that posts on DeafRead that garner more visits or comments usually tend to be those that are filled with inflammatory statements, flamers in the comments, and a general lack of respect towards others.

What I would like to see in 2009 is for the deaf community to leave behind that infighting and rally behind true causes that impact us all.  Causes such as deaf education, lobbying for IDEA to be fully funded (with a few changes in how it is defined and enforced), fighting for captions in movie theaters and on the web (Bill Creswell does an AWESOME job of getting the word out on that kind of stuff.  Kudos to Bill.), talk about what YOU are doing to help improve the lives of the deaf and hard of hearing in your community, talk about the books that are being or have been written by deaf authors or with deaf characters as their central story line.  Not enough of them, you say?  WRITE ONE YOURSELF.  Tell us about your efforts to get it published or looked at by someone in the theatrical or movie world, and rally behind those that ARE trying to do things like this.

Pardon me if I could care less if Martin Ritchie does well or not on that modeling show, although I do see the importance of supporting a deaf or hard of hearing person in their endeavors.  Pardon me if I think that laws against texting while driving are not only NOT discriminatory towards the deaf and hard of hearing, I SUPPORT THEM.  It's a matter of public safety.  Pardon me if I feel that ALL deaf and hard of hearing people are part of the community of deafness, WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE CULTURALLY DEAF, HAVE A CI, CHOOSE TO SPEAK AS WELL AS SIGN, etc.  Pardon me if I could absolutely NOT give a flying fig if a hearing person is chosen to portray a deaf person in a movie, as long as the storyline remains true to the character, the deaf are portrayed in a positive light, and the deaf person is okay with it.

It's my personal opinion that 2008 was the year of Deaf Apathy in many regards.  We lost some of our luster, in my opinion, and we lost some of our fight.  We directed our energies in often misguided attempts to tear down one portion at the expense of others, or a singular portion.  I don't agree with everything the DBC does or says, nor do I agree with everything NAD does or says, or AG Bell, for that matter.  BUT, I agree that one central thing is in common amongst all of them, and that is that they ALL are for the advancement of opportunities for the deaf and hard of hearing.  Now THAT is something I can get behind.  Civil discourse is the root of our success as a country, as a deaf community, etc.  I'm not saying don't disagree, but be civil about it and see the big picture.  The famous patriot Thomas Paine had a couple of sayings I find extremely pertinent:   "He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from opposition; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach himself."  and "Reputation is what men and women think of us; character is what God and angels know of us."


So, my wish for 2009 is that the deaf community coalesces behind the common goals of improving the lives of the deaf and hard of hearing, from ALL walks of life, and to show true character in doing so.

And so it goes.....

Eddie

 
 
( 12 comments — Leave a comment )
(Anonymous) on January 2nd, 2009 05:10 am (UTC)
I agree. Deaf apathy, a lack of leaders, and a proclivity for merely "preaching to the choir" are sad and corrupting and work in twisted concert to pull other well-meaning activists down. And goes only to serve the intents and "innately righteous" aims of the oppressors, those who carry out ethnocentric aims. Self-sabotage at its finest.

"Oppressors produce and maintain by force the evils which, in their eyes, render the oppressed more and more like what he should be to deserve his fate." - Jean-Paul Sartre
(Anonymous) on January 2nd, 2009 04:36 pm (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Very well said, Eddie.

Did you know I just wrote a book review about a novel featuring a deaf character? Reading it really helped raise my personal deaf awareness of what it might be like to experience deafness as a child. The author who isn't deaf spent time (by this I mean years) in the deaf community and learned ASL before writing the story. I spent alot of time considering my words as I wrote the review because I know on DeafRead posts can be controversial.

Keep up the good work on informing us of what you are doing as an advocate in Kentucky.

All the best for 2009!
Sarah
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on January 2nd, 2009 05:27 pm (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Sarah:

Thank you, it is appreciated. I had no idea about the book review, where might I find it? Isn't it a bit sad, that as a reviewer, you had to carefully consider your words in writing the review so as not to start a flame war on DeafRead? You absolutely should be able to write what you personally felt about the story, without having to worry about things like that.

Looking forward to hearing back from you on where I can find the review! Have a great 2009 yourself!

Eddie
(Anonymous) on January 2nd, 2009 09:01 pm (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Hi Eddie,
Here's the link.
http://speakuplibrarian.blogspot.com/2008/12/deafening-by-frances-itani.html
I think I did write what I felt. It's just that not everyone is as inclusive to us hard of hearing folk as you are. I really appreciated your spelling that out in your post that all of us have a place in advocating for our needs.
Sarah aka speakuplibrarian
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on January 3rd, 2009 02:56 am (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Oh! I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to imply anything bad, also, I didn't put two and two together on your name with SpeakupLibrarian. Can't wait to read the review!

Eddie
(Anonymous) on January 3rd, 2009 09:01 pm (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Eddie,

FYI, you are several of my favorite deaf online blogger(s)!

No matter how ideologically different we are. I still LUV ya!

You raised a good awareness about the cheapening of deaf infightings which weakens our political and linguistic and cultural standings with the rest of world.

I am also with you all the way about the importance of public safety within the ban of texting while driving.

I am a victim of reckless driving by someone, who rather chat up on cell phone than paying the attention to the road.

Anonymous from what he or she said - How true about pathetic behaviors of too many deaf people backstabbed and deflated each other than being a mindful as a community group.

I was truly shocked to see one of the respectable deaf member of our locality resorted to backstabbings. He proudly admitted that I finally see his true color.

What a pitful society we are living in!

RLM
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on January 3rd, 2009 09:28 pm (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Thank you, RLM...You are right, we do differ idealogically, but we can do so in a respectful manner, and always have. Thank you for the comment!

Eddie
(Anonymous) on January 4th, 2009 02:42 pm (UTC)
Eddie,

May I submit that "not giving a fig about (CI/Oral/etc. etc." is in itself an apathetic stance or contributing to the overall apathy?

This is not to say that you can't respect or be friends with someone who holds a view that you don't support.

It is the overall SYSTEM that we need to work on and change (and yes, IDEA, ADA, Captioning are important, but without changes to the SYSTEM, we as a group are not going to get anywhere far).

--Don G.
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on January 4th, 2009 05:06 pm (UTC)
Don:

You may submit that, but it is not true, if you read the whole post, you will see that I simply said I don't give a flying fig about it if someone hearing plays a deaf person AS LONG AS it remains true to character, portrays the deaf in a positive light, and the deaf person portrayed is okay with it. I was referring to one thing specifically, and that is the Matt Hammil hullabaloo that rose up because a hearing person is going to be playing his role in a privately funded movie.

There is nothing apathetic about that, because it is a PRIVATE, PERSONAL choice. It is not worth getting my dander up about it, nor is it worth everyone else getting all up in arms over it.

True, the system needs to be changed, but until we make inroads that allow people the OPPORTUNITY to succeed first within the system in place, we can only hope to focus on attitudes of the general population, the workforce, etc. After all, would not our best advocates be deaf and hard of hearing who work within the system in place now and can say to other decision makers "I'm proof of what can be done, BUT there are some changes that need to take place in the ADA, IDEA, captioning, etc."

The overall post was about apathy. My lack of PERSONALLY caring about whether or not anyone likes or dislikes me for supporting bans on texting while driving, or whether or not anyone else doesn't think a person with a CI is truly deaf or not, etc., is not apathetic, it is me simply saying "This is what I think, and whom I support". You are reading WAY too much into one little phrase I used out of the whole post.

Eddie
(Anonymous) on January 4th, 2009 10:59 pm (UTC)
Indeed. Very good post, Eddie. Some simply read way too much into these things. It's healthy to keep things into perspective rather than go off the deep end drumming up conspiracy theories.

Kokonutguy - aka Mike McConnell
(Anonymous) on January 29th, 2010 11:39 pm (UTC)
Deaf Apathy
Hi there,

I couldn't agree more! There's a real lack of HoH blogs around. There seems to be a lot of blogs written/vlogged by deaf people but the HoH'ers just aren't writing about their experiences.

I'm doing my little bit for what it's worth! http://www.deafness-and-hearingaids.net/

Cheers,
Steve.
Thumpaflash[info]thumpaflash on January 30th, 2010 02:54 am (UTC)
Re: Deaf Apathy
Steve:

Welcome to the world of blogging! I will go check your blog out, and thanks for taking time to read mine. Let me know if any questions.

I grew up HoH, but am completely deaf now so, I see both sides of all of the arguments. One thing you will notice, is that the deaf community is very vocal about the issues impacting them.

Eddie